Fraser Forster: Beating Hart?


With Joe Hart’s performances coming under increasing scrutiny, could Roy Hodgson be forced to look north of the border for England’s No1 goalkeeper? Fraser Forster may not be a household name yet, but the solidly built Celtic stopper has some big European nights ahead in which to prove his worth…



A steady trickle of England fans, it seems, are beginning to wonder if the wave of hype surrounding Joe Hart may have been wish-fulfilment on a grand scale. 

Decent goalie that he is, the thinking goes, maybe he’s not the world-beating stopper they had hoped he might be, and if that really is the case, then no amount of back-page hyperbole, the collective will of a nation or Jedi mind tricks are going to change that. Whether Roy Hodgson believes the hype is a different matter, but if the Manchester City No1 drops more clangers like the one against Scotland, he may have some serious thinking to do.

In that case, England will face a choice: accept Hart, warts and all, or try something different. That something different could just be Celtic’s Fraser Forster.

Called up for the second time by Hodgson, it’s unlikely that the giant Geordie will displace Hart for the clashes with Moldova and Ukraine but it at least shows the coach is thinking about him. And well he might. Forster’s performances with the Hoops last season, especially in the Champions League, were often breathtaking. He certainly more than earned his win bonuses against the likes of Barcelona and Spartak Moscow.

Debate and argument is the essence of following football, though, and of course there’s a vociferous anti-Forster camp, based largely on the fact that he plays in Scotland and is unproven at English Premier League level. The logical, but fundamentally flawed, argument is basically this: if he wasn’t good enough for Newcastle, why is he now good enough for England?

Well, let’s get some context here. Tim Krul, a keeper at least as gifted as anyone England can offer these days, was asserting himself at St James’s Park, and competing with long-standing and reliable club servant Steve Harper. Tough nuts to crack for the new kid on the block. So Forster was loaned out to Paul Lambert’s Norwich, where he was voted the club’s Player of the Year. That still wasn’t enough to get a look-in back at his parent club, so he was shipped out again, this time to Glasgow’s east end where Lambert’s old mucker Neil Lennon was struggling to fill the hole left by the departed ‘Holy Goalie’ Artur Boruc.

This is when his development began in earnest; and what the “Newcastle’s third choice” brigade should note is that in his time in Scotland he has improved beyond all recognition. He wasn’t an overnight success and he didn’t win Celtic fans over instantly. Opinion was divided, but he was generally accepted as the best option available under the circumstances. He was a solid shot-stopper and a fine athlete, but he lacked confidence and command, wasn’t great with his feet, and when high balls came into the box he’d be stuck to his line like a rock star in a VIP lounge.

Lennon was very vocal about his faith in Forster, though, and brought him back for a second season on loan. Suddenly he looked a more assured and convincing prospect altogether and did enough to persuade Lennon, and Celtic’s notoriously frugal chief executive, Peter Lawell, to part with two million quid to secure his services on a permanent basis.

This was a significant investment by Celtic’s standards and, while a portion of the fans still howled for Shay Given, Forster went about reassuring them he was worth the money. His consistency improved, and by the time Celtic’s Champions League campaign was underway in earnest, he had firmly established himself as a fans’ favourite. The group stages and his resultant heroics culminated in the clamour for him to be included in the England squad, and Hodgson finally took note towards the end of the season.

So where are we now? Forster’s a fairly mature goalie, with four seasons’ football behind him, including experience in the Champions League, Europa League, SPL and English Championship. His ability as a shot-stopper has never been in doubt. You’d almost make him favourite in a one-on-one, such is his massive frame and his ability to make it appear even bigger to an onrushing forward. Any concerns over his kicking have been allayed and he’s also developed the key attribute for any Celtic keeper: impeccable concentration. A Celtic goalkeeper can be twiddling his thumbs for long spells, with all the action taking place in the other half, but when the call to action comes you have to be ready, and Forster inevitably is.

Aerial dominance is probably still his weakest point. Two years ago he wouldn’t have come off his line – now he does, but he doesn’t always get it right. One thing you can be sure of, though, is that he’s working in it. Press interviews show him to be a student of the craft, and incredibly focused on self-improvement. He practices yoga to develop his flexibility and makes no secret of his desire to get better. His progress at Celtic has been dramatic, and his focus and attitude ensure that it will continue to be so.

Ultimately, whether Forster gets the England call is likely to depend on his profile, and whether he’s appearing on Roy’s radar. Had Celtic slipped on the Kazakhstani banana skin in their qualifying play-off, Forster wouldn’t have been in the Champions League and would have lost his primary platform for proving himself south of the border. But with qualification ensured and another string of top-class opponents heading to Celtic Park, the big man has a chance to force himself further into the England coach’s consciousness. If he can keep Messi, Neymar, Balotelli and Ajax’s loan star Bojan Krkic at bay, he must be good enough for England … mustn’t he?

John Clarke is a freelance scribbler, media lecturer, music snob and proudly blinkered Celtic fan. He has worked for the BBC, numerous magazines and newspapers, and for food. You can follow him on Twitter @johnclarke1
Keep up to date with all the latest from TheInsideLeft by following us on Twitter @theinsidelefty or by joining us on Facebook at

5 thoughts on “Fraser Forster: Beating Hart?

  1. dave c says:

    So joe has a couple of let downs and now he’s no good ??..Get a life golden gloves last 3 season’s best defence last season , sorry foster not at the same school never mind class

    • Mickey1888 says:

      Sorry i’d have to disagree. After seeing every game of Forster & watching MOTD weekly, plus a fair few full Man City games I’d say there really is not much between these keepers, & that Forster drops less clangers & is better on 1v1 situations. Although like Hart, FF’s form has not been as good as before Christmas 2012.

  2. allymonc says:

    I’ll say straight away I’m a Celtic fan and that I’m not convinced by Forster. To my mind he’s okay, nothing more than that. The flaws identified in the article are (in my opinion) still there. He has to be more commanding when the ball comes into the box, I’d like him to come off his line quicker than he does and his kicking is painful to watch. Modern keepers should be able to distribute the ball effectively and I’m afraid the big man just can’t. He is, as has been pointed out a superb shotstopper but does have a habit of pushing shots back into the ‘danger zone’ rather than to safety (he’s not alone in this of course). Thankfully as a Scot I don’t have to worry about who plays in goal for England, it appears they have one good keeper on a poor run of form and then a collection of average keepers who occasionally have a few good games that elevate them from the pack. I’m not criticising the article by the way, it was a good piece I just disagreed with it.

  3. Hugh Jass says:

    I am also a Celtic fan, and i have to agree with you with regards to his command of the box, he had appeared to have alleviated this problem but against large sides he still struggles coming out to meet the ball. However i must agree with allymonc and not with you on his kicking, which is to put it kindly abysmal, his long passes toward the strikers rarely if ever find a target and a lot of the time he ends up ballooning it out the park. Having said that he is a very good shot stopper and in my opinion, better than Ben Foster and John Ruddy, but at the minute in Hodgson’s mind he is 4th choice so him replacing Hart seems very unlikely at the minute

  4. jocky bhoy says:

    I think everyone doesn’t want this to become another Celtic forum, but…

    I am pleased Big Fraser is getting to rub shoulders with the English elite, it can only benefit, him, England and of course Celtic. Hart is blessed by having world class defenders in front of him, Forster kind of has a revolving door at centreback at Celtic Park. I think that is part of his problem deciding on coming for corners. Crosses he’s OK with IMO. He is a great shot stopper, is pretty good against pens. Celtic haven’t had a reliable target man since Big Bad John Hartson (JVoH was a brief replacement) and I think that England would be happy enough playing the ball through the team rather than route1ing it, so again, the criticisms of Forster might not be as applicable in an England side.

    Blood the Bhoy against some of the lesser sides and give yourself some options Roy.

Leave a Reply


Get every new post on this blog delivered to your Inbox.

Join 861 other followers:

Or subscribe to the RSS feed by clicking on the counter: